Our Work for a Nation Called Indonesia

Working in Silence with the Vice President of the Republic of Indonesia

Gibran Rakabuming Raka

2024-2026

Summary:

I am not a campaigner, nor someone assigned to build the image of the Vice President of the Republic of Indonesia. This piece is a personal record of my working journey as Assistant to the Special Staff of the Vice President of the Republic of Indonesia, Gibran Rakabuming Raka. As assistant to Special Adviser, I have experienced many things in the six months since I was appointed to the Office of the Special Staff of the Vice President (SKWP), especially my interactions with the Vice President, both direct and indirect, in my work of helping the vice president carry out his duties through the special staff. This record is a witness to a young vice president and how he does his work without needing media attention or excessive commentary on the way Mas Gibran or Mas Wapres (as we call him) works in silence. Mas Gibran’s closeness to and care for ordinary people and for young people like himself are real proof that the work of a vice president can be meaningful. The content and opinions in this piece are entirely my responsibility as the author. No one forced or pushed me to write it. I wrote it because I was moved as a professional, an academic, and someone who cares about the future of the young generation, the future leaders of this country, represented by a person named Gibran Rakabuming Raka.

*This version is translated from the original Indonesian language verse with the help of AI using Claude Opus 5.5.

Introduction

The first two years of the administration of the 8th President, Prabowo Subianto, and Vice President Gibran Rakabuming Raka were not easy years for the Indonesian nation and state. With the geopolitical crisis made worse by a global energy crisis, the government faced many limitations. Even so, policy on behalf of the Indonesian people had to keep moving, along with fulfilling the campaign promises Prabowo-Gibran made during the 2024 Presidential Election (Pilpres). These promises took the form of the National Priority Programs, and above all the promise to create “19 Million Jobs,” which was entrusted to the vice president. This political promise colored the short journey of the number two person in the republic, familiarly called Mas Wapres.

My chance to interact directly with Mas Wapres came a few months after I joined the Secretariat of the Vice President as assistant to Special Adviser in May 2026. I remember that at the time the special staff asked me to personally present a book that had just been published, an edited volume, titled “Decentralization, Democracy, and Local Politics in Indonesia,” published by Routledge City University of Hong Kong. The book represents the hard work of us, 22 authors from various countries, to make sense of how decentralization and democracy have developed in our beloved country after 25 years. In line with the mandate the president gave the vice president to oversee two major agendas, accelerating Papua’s special autonomy and regional autonomy, the book was expected to help his work.The meeting finally took place on Tuesday, August 3, 2026 at 13:00 in his office at the vice presidential palace. As an academic with a background in political science and policy analysis, meeting Mas Wapres was of course a chance to test directly what I had read in the literature and research about this young figure, who has been widely talked about since his time as Mayor of Solo. Together with the special staff, I walked through the corridors of the vice presidential palace to the door of the vice president’s office. We were welcomed by Gibran’s Personal Assistant, who asked us to wait until we got a signal from inside telling the two of us to come in.

I cannot describe how I felt, as an ordinary citizen, to have the chance to meet and interact with the vice president. It was a privilege that I am still grateful for, as part of the story of my life and career. Meeting Mas Wapres changed the way I had seen this controversial vice president, who faces “tests” every day, both in public and online.

Far from seeming arrogant, Mas Wapres welcomed us very politely and invited us to sit. He did not receive us from behind his desk, but straight away invited us to sit on the guest chairs lined up neatly to the right of the entrance. After the special staff explained the purpose of our visit, I was asked to introduce myself directly to Mas Wapres and to hand him a copy of the book. He took the book and turned the pages one by one while listening to me tell the story of how the book was written and summarize its message for Indonesia’s future.

These two interactions completely shattered the impression I had held of Mas Wapres.The moment I thought would be met coldly, without any response, turned into an interesting discussion that I had never imagined. Mas Wapres focused on the structure of decentralization that the government should keep fighting for. The government must be close to the people. A problem such as the condition of the temporary shelters (huntara) in Aceh after the floods and landslides in November 2025, which I raised as a case example, was followed up right away. Mas Wapres got up from his seat, walked to his desk, and took a small orange notebook with the gold logo of the vice president’s office. He wrote a note for his staff to look into, while asking the special staff who was on duty in the field. I never expected that Mas Gibran, whom many people call “planga-plongo… empty,” would show me none of the behavior he has been accused of.

The conversation continued. This time I presented the manuscript of a collaborative study I did with several others, Dr. Afrimadona, Dimas Ramadhan from Populi Center, Professor Thomas Pepinsky from Cornell University, and Dr. Ehito Kimura from the University of Hawaii at Manoa, titled “Fragmented Memory: Awareness of and Support for Mass Violence in Contemporary Indonesia,” which was later published by the prestigious journal Asian Survey. I was very surprised to find that Mas Gibran paid close attention to the words I used to help him understand our research. The data and methodology were laid out with statistics that might be hard for lay readers. Once again, Mas Wapres convinced me that he understood the discussion, by finding precisely the statistics I mentioned in our conversation among the pages of the rather thick manuscript. The manuscript was written in English, not Indonesian, and he looked relaxed reading it quickly.

I had never imagined it, but my interaction with Mas Wapres was very productive. It left me with no doubt that he is not the person many people have described, in a cynical tone, all this time.

First Working Visit with the Vice President

Months before, then came the time when I accompanied the special staff, for the first time, on the Vice President’s working visit to Aceh, which was still struggling in several locations after the recent floods and landslides. I clearly remember that Mas Wapres was moved when he saw a social media post of children in elementary school uniforms crossing a river on a simple rope, because the bridge had broken in the flood at a disaster site in Aceh.

On Monday, June 8, 2026, Mas Wapres and the team set off for the location on the state aircraft, leaving Halim Perdana Kusuma airport before dawn. As someone who had never followed such strict state protocol, I was very nervous and afraid of making a mistake that could embarrass the special staff or other members of the vice president’s team. I followed every instruction and watched my behavior, all the more because I was seated in the same row as Mas Gibran’s Personal Assistant.

It was a rare opportunity in my life: flying on the same plane as a vice president to visit citizens who were suffering hardship. The trip was full of challenges, given the difficult and remote terrain. We traveled by land and by air, using helicopters to reach remote places. Not many people could accompany Mas Gibran all the way to the disaster site. I had the extraordinary chance to join part of the delegation in three special helicopters, while the rest stayed at the airport in Medan.

When we arrived, I saw how the vice president met the people who were cheering for him. People who had long asked for the state to be present among them had their wish fulfilled by Mas Wapres. He was not only present but took real action, giving help even without being asked when he saw schoolchildren running to stand along the road to greet the vice president’s delegation. Books and stationery were handed out right away, even though it was not on the schedule, which sent the logistics team scrambling. As a young man, his unwillingness to be bound by protocol and his spontaneity colored the working visit, and sometimes left the accompanying staff in a panic.

At every location, Mas Wapres went straight to meet the leaders and workers sent to rebuild the infrastructure that had been destroyed, including bridges and schools. He did not let the chance to listen to their explanations simply pass by. Mas Gibran showed his care and appreciation for the workers by asking about their difficulties and what they needed next to keep the rehabilitation work going. The locations were very far from development, which left the communities affected by the disaster with immense difficulty in getting access to health care, decent housing, education, and above all their livelihoods, which had vanished in an instant, swallowed by the floods.

In the middle of the crowd cheering Mas Gibran’s arrival, a man pushed forward, sobbing right in front of Mas Gibran, and told him how hard it was for him to get medical care and medicine. Mas Gibran immediately ordered his staff to act quickly to help, without waiting long, before the tears of a suffering citizen ran dry.

This did not happen only once, but again and again with different people. It made me think that behind the indifferent manner of a young man, and the accusations that he distracts himself by playing with a rubber band, fidgeting without empathy, the reality in the field was not like that at all. This is Mas Gibran’s own unique way of staying focused on his task, which sadly many people misunderstand.

The people do not need officials who show up displaying luxury and arrogance. They only need the person they chose to be among them, to listen, and to respond to their needs without any pretense.

The Quiet Record of the Vice President’s Work

Working for six months with a great team under the leadership of Special Adviser gave us the opportunity to learn how to think and act in our position as servants of the people. Our different backgrounds and ages complemented each other, all for the sole purpose of making Mas Wapres’s work programs a success, programs that are indeed aimed at marginalized groups.

First, the promise to create 19 million jobs has often been a target of political mockery because Mas Wapres was unable to deliver it. We in the SKWP team worked seriously to find ways for job seekers, to prove that efforts to fulfill the promise are still going on. Mas Wapres’s room to move was very limited.

It was hard for him to strategically change schemes such as Zero-cost Labour Migration, which connects the skills of migrant job seekers with foreign labor markets. This proven scheme, proposed by diaspora activists, helps send migrant workers to fill job offers for nurses and health workers in countries such as Japan, without charging the prospective workers anything at all. The scheme is very friendly to prospective migrant workers who come from low-income backgrounds.

Second, the follow-up to the Indonesia Future Talent Academy (IFTA) initiative, which SKWP started across teams to strengthen the academic and leadership capacity of young Indonesian talent through an internship program at the Vice President’s office. The SKWP team under Special Adviser developed this scheme further to connect policy analysts in government offices, especially within Setwapres, with high school and university graduates. The aim of this initiative is to give young people the chance to understand how policies are formulated and decided in government.

Mas Wapres’s visits to disaster areas, bringing university students along, were a real step to show them that, when policy directly concerns people in hardship, many things need to be considered beyond academic analysis. The controversy over students accompanying Mas Wapres grew large because it was linked to a “feud among the ruling elite.” This was the clearest point at which Mas Wapres consciously chose to keep working in silence. Without noise, but with a good impact on the public.

Our advocacy to follow up IFTA went as far as introducing it at the international level, through an SKWP working mission to the United States, especially to Cornell University and Northern Illinois University. The visit was an important chapter in moving forward IFTA’s mission to build a well-rounded next generation of the nation, with strong academic, analytical, and leadership abilities, to contribute to the homeland in the future. For example, Cornell’s Jeb E. Brooks School of Public Policy is interested in building more profiles of international graduates who play active roles in public policy in their own countries. The IFTA scheme is attractive to them because it links the Vice President’s scholarship, LPDP, and the study programs offered at foreign universities such as Cornell SPP. Both sides would benefit if the initiative continued. Indonesia would gain enormous benefits from developing its human resources through academic work in the future.

There are many other things the SKWP team has done to advocate for the issues of marginalized communities, such as paying attention to the preservation of customs and the richness of the arts in the indigenous community of Agats, in Asmat, Papua. Many other proposals have been drafted for follow-up, such as the issue of sexual violence in pesantren (Islamic Boarding School), West Nusa Tenggara; the issue of human rights violations in Papua; and much more work with impact on the wider public that was not widely covered by the media, because Mas Wapres indeed chose to work in silence.

Preparing the Vice President’s Workplace in IKN

My last contribution as assistant to the special staff, together with the team, in carrying out state duties was to make sure that the Nusantara Capital City (IKN) in Kalimantan was ready to be Mas Gibran’s workplace. In line with President Prabowo’s mandate, the vice president would be assigned to oversee the development of IKN up close. For that, the vice presidential palace and the infrastructure construction had to keep moving, despite heavy funding challenges and the forest and peatland fires sweeping across much of Indonesia, including IKN. Without any prejudice in our minds, our team worked and appreciated the results of the oversight by Pak Basuki, assisted by Pak Bimo and their staff. The situation in October was still not favorable, because of the hot weather and the gray sky covered by smoke from forest fires in the peatland areas of Central Kalimantan.

The trip to IKN left its own impression, because it dispelled people’s assumption that IKN’s development has stalled and become a “ghost” city, a huge waste of the state budget (APBN). As one of the people who had the chance to visit IKN, and especially to check the readiness of the vice presidential palace firsthand, I saw that the supporting infrastructure, the office, and the residence of the vice president appeared ready to use.

My curiosity about the life of civil servants (ASN), especially the very young civil servants posted in IKN, was answered when I met some of them. They are remarkable young women and men, eager to apply their knowledge for the sake of ecological harmony between IKN and its surrounding buffer areas. Their varied fields of study, from water science to plant nursery science, strengthened my belief, as someone who is also an educator, that the hope of building a class of young civil servants who face the future with optimism lies in them. IKN gives them hope, because there they can make their mark, far from the negative influence of a civil service environment that is often labeled as unproductive. In our minds, the SKWP team going directly to observe the readiness of the vice president’s office and residence meant that the time for us to finally work from IKN was near.

Time passed, and October was almost over. Problems kept hitting the Setwapres office, related to several legal issues over the validity of the questionable certificate of equivalence (Suket) for Mas Wapres’s high school diploma. The Constitutional Court (MK) decision that no high school diploma document was found pushed forward the desire to remove Mas Wapres through parliament. The political escalation was very sharp, political elites maneuvered, our office dimmed, and the passion to work disappeared. The diploma issue kept rolling, with a lawsuit also at the State Administrative Court (PTUN), but the Supreme Court (MA) had already struck its gavel, marking a dark chapter for the legitimacy of a vice president whose validity had been stripped away. The MA ruling stated that Mas Wapres’s Suket was declared void and must be destroyed. This meant Mas Wapres’s only defense was at the PTUN, while parliament moved toward impeachment.

As the demands for resignation or impeachment aimed at Mas Wapres blew with such force, 10 November became the deciding chapter, when parliament would hold its first plenary session after the recess.

The scenario to undermine the Vice President’s legitimacy was complete, through the MK decision together with the MA decision. Time moved without obstacles for those pressing the Vice President to make a decision as soon as possible, racing against the impeachment effort through the DPR, the house of the people. The day everyone was waiting for came. Our team had no power over Mas Wapres’s decision. His attitude and actions all this time were not a reflection of his true self, but rather of political considerations for the sake of the nation and state. Political choices made consciously, amid bureaucratic and coordination obstacles, meant that the role of a vice president could not function optimally at all.

Tuesday, 10 November 2026 became a historic milestone for a country with a long history of elite division caused by the politics of divide et impera. This time the same politics moved at the level of the native elite, and the victim fell at the very top of leadership: Gibran Rakabuming Raka, with full awareness, announced his resignation. Amid the “burning” spirit of the people’s representatives scrambling for the chance to replace him, Gibran stopped them in their tracks by handing his resignation letter to President Prabowo, and then to the People’s Consultative Assembly on Wednesday, 11 November 2026. This final step, which should make the people’s representatives aware, is a hard slap for them that the game is not over yet. The tearing apart of the tumpeng (a iconic ceremonial cone-shaped rice dish from Javanees cuisine)  of power now moves into their arena. The political consequence they should have realized in the current era of government is that their voices will not matter, not as much as the word of the highest ruler.

Closing

I end this piece here. Further developments are beyond consideration and happen outside our team. All political calculations are beyond the control of Mas Wapres, who has resigned, let alone us.

Allow me, as someone who was once part of the SKWP team, to congratulate Mas Wapres: you have passed the hard test of a leader with great wisdom. This is the most basic requirement, the core ingredient that should be engraved in a future leader. Mas Wapres has it now. Regardless of my choice in the past, I truly appreciate Mas Wapres’s presence during my time on the SKWP team, as well as the resignation he chose with full awareness, the awareness of a national leader.

The world may sneer, and it is also the world that will witness where this nation is heading. As an academic who worked in silence while accompanying the silent steps of Mas Gibran, and with all due respect to political pundits and those who worship the glory of power, this country is not doing well (RI).

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

My Journal as an AIFIS-Luce Research Fellow 2024

Cornell University-Northern Illinois University-Loyola University Chicago

The Journey Has Begun

As I began writing the proposal narrative for the AIFIS-Luce Fellowship application, the first thing that came to mind was how to channel my long-standing passion for this research into a productive and well-structured fellowship agenda. This project actually extends an area omitted from my dissertation. My dissertation on territorial change and conflict in Indonesia was published as a book, with the final chapter newly written as a precursor to this fellowship proposal.

The proposal was built around a central question: What is the impact of inter-ethnic leadership in the provincial governor/deputy governor office on conflict reduction at the provincial level? Additionally, how does inter-ethnic leadership in the district regent/deputy regent office mitigate conflict during a new province campaign?

This project, therefore, aims to investigate the impact of ethnic power sharing on decentralization in Indonesia, focusing on the post-Regional Autonomy Law 22/1999 era up to the present. Through a panel study of 34 provinces and 514 districts from 2000 to 2023, this research explores how the absence of ethnic power sharing at the provincial level influences minority districts’ tendencies to seek autonomy by challenging the existing provincial government. This study also examines the relationships between power sharing, small-scale conflicts, and Indonesia’s territorial autonomy policies within its ethnically diverse landscape, considering other variables like local welfare.

Through intensive consultations with U.S.-based university faculty experts in this field, access to their library resources, and participation in seminars and discussions, I have been able to gather extensive information to enhance my understanding and refine methodologies for future ethno-territorial studies.

To keep it brief, on October 14, 2024, I traveled from Indonesia to the United States, a journey that marked the start of an extraordinary experience as an AIFIS-Luce Research Fellow. My interactions with renowned scholars and experts in Indonesian, Southeast Asian, and international relations had expanded my professional network to include scholars across disciplines. These encounters, occurring in offices, classrooms, seminars, and even casual lunches or dinners, underscored the immense value of building networks with scholars not only in my field of interest but also across various academic disciplines.

I have documented most of these experiences through social media and in my journal. The memories are invaluable, although only some can be included in this report. The rest await incorporation into my next research endeavors. Here are my activities during my six-week research fellowship trip to Cornell University, New York; Northern Illinois University, Illinois; and Loyola University Chicago.

Academic Collaborations and Mentorship

Cornell University, Ithaca, New York (Department of Government/South East Asia Program)-Professor Thomas Pepinsky (October 14 to November 1, 2024)

On October 14, 2024, my journey as an AIFIS-Luce Fellow began with flights from Jakarta to Narita, Newark, and finally Ithaca. Upon arrival at Tompkins International Airport in Ithaca, I was warmly welcomed by Donna L. Pinnisi, Coordinator of Scholar Services at Cornell

University’s Einaudi Center. She drove me directly to the International Scholar House, where I would be staying. During my stay, Donna has been incredibly helpful, showing me around the center, connecting me with SEAP officers, and answering any questions about Cornell and the Ithaca area.

Settling in as an AIFIS-Luce Research Fellow

On my second day at Cornell, I officially began my work as a research fellow, though jet lag initially made it challenging to focus. I fought through the effects of travel, braving Ithaca’s drizzling, gloomy weather at a chilly 43°F (6°C). At the International Scholar House, I found a

comfortable home equipped with five bedrooms, two and a half bathrooms, kitchen, spacious living room, and ample space for work and discussion. I shared this space with other international scholars from China, Canada, South Korea, and Venezuela, enriching my experience through diverse academic and cultural exchanges.

Cornell University is spectacular in the fall, with vibrant foliage welcoming me and infusing me with energy and enthusiasm. I was fortunate to receive valuable guidance from my research advisor, Professor Thomas B. Pepinsky, Walter F. LaFeber Professor of Government and Public Policy at Cornell and a Nonresident Senior Fellow at the Brookings Institution.

Recently stepping down as Director of the Southeast Asia Program (SEAP), he continues to play an instrumental role in my research. Our discussions encompassed theories in comparative politics, methodologies, nationalism, and democratization, particularly within the Southeast Asian context.

Exploring Cornell’s Resources

A highlight of my fellowship was diving into the renowned Echols Collection at Olin Library, especially the Koch’s Asia collection. The library’s vast resources, including rare archives and extensive online materials, were invaluable for my study. Given the limitations of resources in Indonesia, this access has been a precious asset, allowing me to immerse myself in literature that directly supports my research.

It was a delight to meet Jeffrey Peterson, the assistant curator of the Echols Library.  Jeffrey was incredibly helpful in guiding me through the vast, almost overwhelming collection at Cornell’s Olin Library. Navigating this extensive library felt like venturing into uncharted territory, and his assistance was effective in orienting me throughout the collections. He took the time to walk me through the library’s dedicated online search engine for Asian collections, ensuring I could find the materials I needed for my research. Beyond the technical help, Jeffrey was a pleasure to converse with; our discussions ranged widely, covering topics on U.S., Asian, and Southeast Asian ethnic politics. He generously shared his knowledge of books, journals, opinion pieces, and archives, which provided a wealth of resources that will undoubtedly be beneficial for my research.

While I am conducting research on Indonesia and Southeast Asia, I will also be doing some research on world politics.Professor Peter J. Katzenstein, a famous international relations expert who takes a constructivist perspective, graciously allowed me to sit in on one of his lectures and observe him teach on the topic of “Exceptionalism Questioned: America and Europe.” Professor Katz has an exceptionally engaging approach to structuring his class. While some might find his presentations challenging, particularly those unfamiliar with the intricacies of small European economies, his technique of connecting complex material to relatable cultural references—such as a Danish film set during World War II—is both fascinating and effective.

What made the lecture even more memorable was his clever use of Aesop’s fable about a frog to ground the discussion in a universally accessible story. This pedagogical style not only makes international relations concepts more approachable but also helps students

understand how small economies navigate and survive within a competitive, capitalistic landscape. It was a truly top-rated example of how to make IR relatable and engaging. A good segway before “shifting my paradigm” to the United States Politics course that will be held on a different campus the following month.

SEAP hosts a program called the Gatty Lecture Series, where world-renowned scholars present their research to Cornell’s academic community. These scholars primarily study Southeast Asia from various disciplines and perspectives. I was fortunate to attend two lectures during my visit to Cornell. The first event that I attended was on October 24. The presentation was an archaeological study by Dr. Hieu Phung from Rutgers University–New Brunswick titled “River Works and Dai Viet’s State-Building at the Transition to the Little Ice Age.”

I also took part in the graduate seminar on Comparative Politics that was taught by Professor Pepinsky. The session offered readings that were very informative regarding identity and classification. The seminar, which was full of Ph.D. students from a variety of different backgrounds, provided an environment that were fundamental to my research.

The academic discussions provided a critical overview that can lay the basic foundation of my research. All of these student-faculty engagement made me wonder about ethnic power-sharing and territorial autonomy across horizon. Sitting in this seminar class really broadened my perspective through cross-cultural academic conversations.

Additionally, I observed a class taught by Ms. Jolanda Pandin, a senior lecturer of Indonesian language, providing me valuable insights into the academic representation of Indonesian studies in the U.S. Her teaching and interaction with the United States undergraduate students help me to understand the importance of exchanging knowledge, understanding cultural context, as well as increasing language skills to get a sense of who we are in the global interconnected world.

Engagement with Cornell’s Academic Community

Taking advantage of the unseasonably warm afternoon weather, I enjoyed exploring Cornell’s scenic campus. A memorable walk took me to the entrance Welcome Center, along the trail to Beebe Lake, and toward the Cornell Jeb E. Brooks School of Public Policy, where I would meet with faculty the following week. Along the way, I was impressed by ingenious art installation near the school.

As an associate professor in the School of Public Administration and senior researcher at Populi Center for Public Opinion and Policy Research, primarily focused on teaching and researching areas related to public policy, I thoroughly enjoyed taking a preliminary stroll around the Cornell Brooks School of Public Policy. This casual exploration gave me a chance to appreciate the layout, ambiance, and academic environment of the school, enriching my

sense of anticipation for the upcoming formal meeting with its high level administrators/faculty member, including Assistant Dean of Alumni Affairs and Development, Haley Weiss and Cornell’s fund raiser person. Knowing that eventually I would involve in a more in-depth engagement with them at Professor Pepinsky’s office, I found it helpful to immerse myself in the school’s atmosphere beforehand, setting the stage for meaningful discussions on areas of mutual interest in public policy and administration.

Final Days at Cornell

My last days at Cornell were marked by attending another Gatty Lecture Series at Kahin Center, which features world-class speakers on Southeast Asian topics. I had the opportunity to attend one last lecture by an Indonesian academic—which was enlightening.

This second lecture was held on October 31, presented by Dwi Noverini Djenar from the University of Sydney and focused on “Exonerative Accounts and the Circulation of Labels: Examples from Indonesian Political Talk.”

These experiences have left a lasting impact on me, building a foundation for future academic and professional collaborations. As I look forward to my next research destinations, I am deeply grateful for the knowledge gained, the scholars met, and the network built during my stay at Cornell. From here, I am now prepared to leave Cornell. By next week, November 2, I will begin my second fellowship at Northern Illinois University in DeKalb, Illinois.

Northern Illinois University, DeKalb, Illinois (Department of Political Science)-Professor Scott Schraufnagel (November 2 to November 8, 2024)

I continued my journey to the Northern Illinois University (NIU) in DeKalb, New York, after finishing three weeks of research at Cornell University. I arrived at O’Hare airport in Chicago, Illinois on November 2, 2024. Then, I went to the NIU at DeKalb to continue my research endeavour. NIU is a public research university located in DeKalb, Illinois. Originally called Northern Illinois State Normal School, it was founded in 1895 by Illinois Governor John P. Altgeld. The school was established to provide teachers in Illinois with the opportunity to obtain college degrees. NIU evolved from the original normal school, which was first established in 1857 in Normal, Illinois. In 1895, through an initiative by the state legislature, a board of trustees was created to oversee the Northern Illinois State Normal School, which eventually became NIU as we know it today.

I was feeling very excited because Illinois was the state that I regarded to be my home state in the United States. This was, in fact, my second visit to NIU. The initial trip occurred one week prior to my dissertation defense in 2019. I visited Indonesian friends who had their defense prior to mine.

I stayed at the residence of the late Professor Riswandha Imawan’s eldest son, Rafif Imawan. Professor Riswandha Imawan was a prominent Indonesian scholar on decentralization and democracy from University of Gadjah Mada, Yogyakarta, Indonesia. His contributions were well renowned among scholars studying similar subjects in Southeast Asia. Sadly, Professor Imawan passed away when Rafif was only 19 years old, leaving him to support his two younger brothers and his mother, taking over his father’s role.

Rafif and I recently co-authored a newly published article with other contributors, titled “Authoritarian Nostalgia and Democratic Decline in Indonesia.” I am incredibly proud that our work is now featured on the political science department board. Rafif and I are also colleagues at the Populi Center for Public Opinion and Policy Research. Without wasting much time, since I was only here for a week, I took the opportunity to explore the campus and meet the people I would be engaging with in the coming days.

Taking more Research Advice from the Experts

At NIU, I received a great deal of guidance from Professor Scot Schraufnagel, an expert onelections and the United States Congress. In addition, he has been conducting studies on the leaders of local governments in Indonesia, which makes his expertise as my adviser exceptionally relevant. Professor Schraufnagel’s understanding of U.S. politics was particularly useful in comprehending the 2024 U.S. election that took place on November 5, 2024. The fierce contest between two presidential candidates—Kamala Harris and Tim Walz from the Democratic Party, and Donald Trump and J.D. Vance from the Republican ticket—was closely watched by viewers, political pundits, and statespeople across the globe. With Professor Schraufnagel’s guidance, I gained more knowledge on how to approach my research.

In this regard, Professor Schraufnagel advised me to think critically about the ideal picture I want to project as a scholar studying a phenomenon. His counsel helped me realize that there is nothing more important for a scholar than proving that their intuition about their research is wrong, rather than trying to find ways to justify assumptions. This is the principle of falsification that he reminded me about. I am thankful for his counsel, especially regarding how to expand my research to achieve greater benefits in terms of policy effectiveness. After all, the combination of local leaders’ characteristics—whether from ethnicity, religion, government or non-government backgrounds—may not be valuable in practice if it only answers one question: whether power-sharing arrangements contribute to the likelihood of conflict.

Professor Schraufnagel suggested that I expand my perspectives to consider the benefits of this kind of research. Another important point he reminded me of was the availability of data. If a researcher needs to collect data, they must ensure they understand how feasible data collection will be in the future. This is crucial to think about, which made me realize that I need to speak with more people before returning to Professor Pepinsky for the next steps once this research fellow trip has concluded.

Exploring NIU’s Resources

I took the liberty of roaming around the campus to visit the library, classrooms, facultyoffices, and the college store, where I met “Mission,” the Huskie mascot of NIU. The campus is especially beautiful on a sunny day, with the rich sunlight enhancing its charm. The weather was quite pleasant, with a gentle breeze adding a refreshing touch.

I also visited the Memorial Founders’ Library, which holds a Southeast Asian collection. The collection here is not as extensive as Cornell’s, but it is still substantial enough for readers to explore and study. One aspect I appreciate about the U.S. library system is the option to use interlibrary loans, allowing readers to borrow books from other university libraries. There is even a dedicated section for Indonesian materials, which is especially valuable for my research.

There, I found interesting evidence related to our election propaganda: one campaign team went so far as to manipulate the front page of a renowned newspaper, altering both the front and back pages with their campaign ads to mirror the real edition inside. I was fascinated by how the propaganda machine works in elections, where disinformation has also plagued the US election. I can hardly imagine how it would feel to be a reader of that newspaper, unable to tell the difference between political ads and real coverage. Readers like this could, in some ways, be persuaded by the ads and end up voting as intended by the campaign.

As I had the privilege of watching the election closely, I was also delighted to assist Professor Etin Anwar, a professor in Hobart & William Smith College, Ithaca, New York, in setting up her new podcast on the already active Reducates platform, aimed at engaging with the community of scholars both abroad and in Indonesia.

Additionally, I accepted an offer to be interviewed by Nusantara Television (NTV), the first nationally digital television broadcast network, for a talk show the night before the election, on November 4, 2024. The program aimed to provide Indonesian audiences with insights into the logic of the U.S. election, which happened to take place after the Indonesian election in February. It was a fun activity, especially since the other guest was my dear old college friend, Dr. Teguh Santosa, an international relations scholar from Universitas Islam Negeri, Ciputat, Indonesia.

Another activity I thoroughly enjoyed at NIU was attending lectures and discussions. After the election, I noticed a change in atmosphere—everyone seemed unusually quiet, and not a single student I met brought up the election. In his honors class program on Spies, Lies, and Secret Wars (CIA), Dr. Eric Jones from history department gave me and several Indonesian PhD students at the NIU the opportunity to engage with his honors’ students by sharing our insights on the recent Indonesian election on November 6, 2024. We were then asked to compare these insights with the results of the US election.

The outcome revealed that Donald Trump won a landslide victory, with both houses seemingly dominated by his party, the Republicans. Similarly, after Prabowo won Indonesia’s presidential election by a large margin, he also formed a grand coalition, leaving almost no opposition to challenge his administration. It appears that nations worldwide, both developed and developing, are shifting towards a more authoritarian realm of leadership. Reflecting on the elections in both countries, I observed some shared similarities, particularly the illiberal turn in democracy.

Even classroom discussions felt a bit subdued; it seemed people were growing weary of the constant election talk. However, when the conversation shifted to Indonesia’s election, quite a few students raised their hands to voice their perspectives, showing renewed interest and engagement. I would say, for better or worse, we must move forward as a nation. I mean this for both Indonesia and the US.

For this, I have no definitive statement to make, as I am simply a researcher. I prefer to keep it that way, as I believe that freedom of expression must be accompanied by the responsible gathering and conveying of information in a methodologically sound way.

However, as an academic, I realize the importance of transforming our work to engage with the real world. In this case, we need skills to adapt to the practical realities of policy implementation. I truly value scholars from other countries, like Dr. Jones at NIU, who have a genuine concern for Indonesia and the way its government should be conducted.

Dr. Jones works closely with Indonesian scholars and PhD students to shape Indonesia’s newadministrations, including the new members of Indonesia’s parliament, so that they can perform at their optimum. His extensive knowledge and networking with top-level individuals, including John Brandon from the Asia Foundation, in Washington D.C., the Indonesian government and other offices, make me even more enthusiastic to engage in research collaboration with the NIU folks, including him and his network.

We agreed to take the collaboration to another level by writing a co-edited book volume to evaluate Indonesia’s 25 years of decentralization. Seeing the optimism and enthusiastic vibes from the potential writers, I have gathered my managerial skills to create a team with the help of Rafif Imawan and my co-editor back in Indonesia, Dr. Testriono, who also graduated from NIU. I intend to propose the book to one of the top publishers in the US, UK, or Southeast Asia. I believe this book will be very informative for policymakers in the new Prabowo-Gibran-led administration, especially concerning national and sub-national power relationships in the future.

I also participated in one of the book talks hosted by the Center for Southeast Asia Studies (CSEAS). CSEAS held this book launch event as part of its faculty, student, and community engagement initiatives. Interestingly, the event also served as a means of evaluating a potential new faculty member, providing an innovative approach to assess candidates or scout talent for future faculty positions. I found this format particularly inspiring, and I am considering implementing something similar at my own campus as an effective model for evaluating prospective faculty members.

This time, Paul Chambers, a faculty member in the Social Science department at Naresuan University, shared insights from his book at the CSEAS Fall Lecture Series on November 6, 2024. The talk was particularly interesting because the speaker was an NIU graduate who had conducted research at a university in Thailand. The book itself focused on the concept of a praetorian kingdom, which, to me, illustrated another manifestation of collusion between the military and the monarchy to rule a country. It portrayed a type of praetorian, predatory regime, which is concerning for those of us who still trust democratic systems as the better way to govern a nation.

Final Days at Northen Illinois University

My final days at NIU concluded with completing three article drafts about the U.S. election, which I plan to submit to an Indonesian semi-popular online media platform, such as The Conversation. I am quite satisfied with all the research guidance I received from my NIU advisor, Professor Schraufnagel, the opportunity to speak in Dr. Jones’s class, and the progress made in collaborative research to co-edit a book evaluating 25 years of Indonesian decentralization. This book initiative aligns closely with my own research interests.

Overall, the outcome of my visit to the second destination was gaining a broader understanding of conducting research on decentralization and local governance policy implementation from a comparative perspective. I truly hope to apply this extensive body of knowledge to Indonesia’s regional autonomy frameworks in the near future—of course, after my own research yields fruitful results.

Next, I will head to my final destination, Loyola University Chicago in Chicago, Illinois, which also happens to be my alma mater, where I completed my Ph.D. and later returned as a postdoctoral researcher.

Loyola University Chicago, Chicago, Illinois (Department of Political Science/Center for Research on International Affairs)-Professor Alexandru Grigorescu and Dr. Olga Avdeyeva (November 11 to November 29, 2024)

The final destination of my AIFIS-Luce Research Fellowship activities was Loyola University Chicago, an institution that held a special place in my heart. It was there that I underwent six years of rigorous PhD training, followed by two years of postdoctoral work. On November 11, 2024, I returned to my old university as a visiting scholar, which brought back many cherished memories, and it was an honor to re-engage with a community that had played such a pivotal role in my academic journey.

Loyola University Chicago (LUC) is a Jesuit private research university located in Chicago, Illinois. Established by the Society of Jesus in 1870, it is now one of the largest Catholic universities in the United States. My visiting fellowship took place at the Lake Shore Campus, which is beautifully situated next to the expansive Lake Michigan.

Listing LUC as my final destination was, for me, a meaningful way to reconnect with the community. Additionally, I looked forward to reestablishing ties with Northwestern University, which I had not visited in a long time since leaving the Chicago area. Northwestern has excellent research resources that could be valuable for my future decentralization project. In many ways, this trip has come full circle.

For this final trip, I had several goals in mind. Beyond seeking further research guidance for my study on ethnic power sharing and decentralization, I also aimed to explore how I could contribute in return to this institution.

I was fortunate to have the guidance of two esteemed faculty members who had previously collaborated with me and my institutions back home: Professor Alexandru Grigorescu, an expert in international organizations, and Dr. Olga Avdeyeva, a specialist in public policy and Eastern European politics. Both are faculty members in the Political Science Department. Professor Grigorescu also serves as the director of the newly established Center for Research on International Affairs (CRIA). This center aims to foster collaboration and networking opportunities for faculty members and the policy community, creating an environment conducive to both academic advancement and practical policy engagement.

Research Advancements and Scholarly Contributions to Policy Practice

Since this trip to Loyola University Chicago as a visiting research fellow was my last, I was determined to make the most of it. I outlined three main agendas focused on research, teaching, and collaboration. Alongside receiving guidance for my own research, I attended two cross-disciplinary meetings hosted by the Political Science Department on the second and third Mondays of my three-week stay. These meetings aimed to explore potential research collaborations between LUC faculty and my home institution. Additionally, I delivered a lecture titled Strategic Advocacy in Post-Election Indonesia: Shaping Inclusive Policies for Marginalized Communities to an undergraduate class on political participation and engagement, with a focus on participatory budgeting scheduled on November 25, 2024.

For my research, Professor Grigorescu recommended using large-N studies rather than small-N, emphasizing that focusing less on highly granular data collection would not only save time but also inherently improve the study’s internal validity. He noted that this approach would be particularly effective in a panel study format, allowing for more robust and generalizable findings.

Dr. Avdeyeva provided valuable insights on the global trend of declining democracy and the rise of authoritarian leadership, describing it as an almost unstoppable phenomenon. Drawing from her observations of numerous liberal, developed nations transitioning toward illiberal democracies, she explained that this trend is similarly visible in developing countries like Indonesia. In her view, reversing this trajectory is challenging, but she predicted that once people grow weary of authoritarian rule, a pushback or resistance will eventually emerge. She highlighted how history often repeats itself in such cycles of governance.

Exploring LUC’s Resources

Navigating Loyola’s resources was straightforward, as I was already familiar with the system from my previous roles as a research assistant and part-time instructor during my postgraduate training. I fully utilized my access to Cudahy’s library resources and materials, which proved invaluable for my ongoing research. Additionally, I was grateful to the Political Science Department for providing me with a shared faculty office space. This compact, private workspace was ideal for finalizing my research design and starting to pitch my book idea to potential publishers.

I also used my time in the office to reconnect with former students. One of them visited me to request a letter of recommendation for a master’s program in international relations. It was deeply rewarding to still be able to support my former students, and even more fulfilling to meet her again in person.

Another important activity as a visiting scholar was to get in touch with the community of researchers. Professor Alexandru Grigorescu, as the CRIA director, invited me to the first lunch with faculty members from the Political Science and Anthropology Departments on November 18, 2024. Our research is closely related under one major umbrella theme: gender and resource curse issues.

Dr. Molly Melin (Director of the Political Science Department) focuses on post-conflict peacebuilding resolution among populations living in extractive commodity regions. Dr. Olga Avdeyeva’s research pertains to women’s representation in resource-rich mining areas, and Dr. Paula Talman’s research interest is in gender and water security. We shared our research interests and agreed to continue our discussion to arrange a virtual meeting for the next research collaboration agenda or perhaps set up a panel for a conference in the near future. It was so delightful to learn about these research avenues.

Unexpected Agenda to Visit Other Universities

During my time at LUC, I travelled to the University of Wisconsin-Madison to give a talk. Dr. Eunsook Jung, Assistant Dean in the College of Letters and Science at UW-Madison, reached out to me when I was at Cornell. Dr. Jung, who has known me for a while, follows my activities

on social media and visited the Populi Center in Jakarta earlier this year. She wanted me to present on my recent co-authored article, Authoritarian Nostalgia and Democratic Decline in Contemporary Indonesia. This unexpected opportunity left me feeling very grateful. At last, I had a chance to visit this campus, which so many people describe as beautiful.

The talk at University of Wisconsin at Madison went very well. This Friday Forum held on November 22, 2024 will be a memorable one for me since this was my last two talks that I was assigned so far before I ended my mission as an AIFIS-Luce Research Fellow.  In this precious opportunity, I had a fruitful discussion with professors, graduate and undergraduate students across discipline, and community members who were interested into Southeast Asian programs. As the outreach director for UW-Madison’s Center for Southeast Asian Studies, Dr. Mary McCoy gave her opening remarks followed by the speaker’s introduction by Dr. Eunsook Jung, the Assistant Dean, Academic Deans’ Services, College of Letters and Science.

In this session, I presented findings from my previous research project with Dr. Ehito Kimura from the University of Hawaii at Manoa, Dr. Afrimadona, Rafif Pamenang Imawan, and Dimas Ramadhan from Populi Center for Public Opinion and Policy Research. The topic sparked significant interest, particularly given the sensitivity of the recent elections in both the United States and Indonesia. Despite the delicate nature of the subject, the discussion was thoughtful and constructive, taking place in an open and supportive academic setting.

The time flew by quickly, as the audience actively engaged with the material and asked compelling questions. Unfortunately, as the session neared its end, many questions remained unanswered when Dr. McCoy, serving as moderator, announced that the time was up. Nonetheless, the event left a lasting impression on me, underscoring the importance of these academic exchanges in fostering mutual understanding and deeper inquiry into critical issues.

Final Days at LUC

During the final week of my visit as a research fellow at LUC, Professor Alexandru Grigorescu, the director of CRIA, kindly invited me to lunch with Dr. Clifford Shultz, a distinguished faculty member from the Quinlan School of Business. Dr. Shultz is highly regarded for his research in corporate social responsibility, particularly in the context of environmental sustainability.

Our conversation revealed Dr. Shultz’s strong interest in expanding his research within the Southeast Asia region, building on his past projects in countries such as Cambodia and Vietnam. He expressed enthusiasm about the possibility of including Indonesia in his future studies. Looking ahead, Dr. Shultz shared his intention to visit Indonesia next year and proposed the idea of organizing a mini-seminar in collaboration with me and my affiliated institutions. This prospect of future academic collaboration was both exciting and inspiring, offering another meaningful avenue to strengthen ties between our institutions and foster impactful research on sustainability in the region.

After lunch on November 25, 2024, I was scheduled to give my last talk as an AIFIS-Luce Research Fellow on Civic Engagement and Participatory Budgeting at Loyola University Chicago in one of the Political Science classes managed by Raluca Pavel, a PhD candidate in International Relations. With Thanksgiving around the corner, the class was not as fully packed as usual. However, we managed to complete the session smoothly, ending with several interesting discussions with students and faculty.

The theme of Civic Engagement and Participatory Budgeting resonated deeply with me due to my active collaboration with INKLUSI and its partner NGOs and CSOs (Mitra INKLUSI). Together, we work on issues affecting women and marginalized populations, aiming to amplify community voices at the national policymaking level. These issues are systematically gathered and organized at the local village level and are later consolidated during two Musyawarah Nasional Perempuan (National Women’s Congress). These congresses have culminated in nine priority issues:

  1. Poverty (Social Protection) – Addressing economic disparities and ensuring access to social safety nets.
  2. Women Workers – Advocating for migrant workers, domestic workers, and victims of human trafficking, alongside promoting decent work conditions and job opportunities for people with disabilities.
  3. Prevention of Child Marriage – Combatting early marriage through awareness and legislative efforts.
  4. Economic Empowerment of Women – Facilitating opportunities for women to improve their economic standing.
  5. Women’s Leadership – Encouraging and increasing women’s participation in decision-making processes.
  6. Women’s Health – Focusing on mental health, reproductive health rights, and adolescent health.
  7. Women and the Environment – Promoting sustainable natural resource management and supporting indigenous communities.
  8. Violence Against Women and Children – Preventing and addressing various forms of gender-based violence.
  9. Women and Children in Conflict with the Law – Advocating for fair treatment and rehabilitation for women and children in legal systems.

In this lecture session, I helped the undergraduate students learn about civic engagement for advocating those nine issues to be connected with Indonesia’s new administration, which was recently installed on October 20, 2024. These issues were meant to be incorporated into the strategic planning and budgeting systems of the relevant ministries and agencies that deal with women and marginalized population issues. The students were very keen to understand how the engagement scenario had been laid out and how the actors involved in the advocacy strategy mattered to the success of the policy.

End of the Beginning

Thank you to AIFIS-Luce for your generous fellowship. As an associate professor at NIPA Schoolof Administration and Senior Researcher at Populi Center, the grant has been invaluable in expanding my knowledge, networking opportunities, and enhancing the capacity of my organizations. I am pleased to share my wonderful academic journey across the continent, both in the United States and Indonesia. The fellowship has also been incredibly beneficial for me as a middle-career faculty member, allowing me to connect with a world-class community of researchers and professors. There are various ways to build collaborations between scholars in both countries.

I would like to conclude by expressing my gratitude to the outstanding individuals who have helped me build my capacity as a scholar in political science and public policy through the fellowship. These include the President of the AIFIS Executive Board, Robert Hefner, and other board members, Megan Hewitt (Executive Director of AIFIS), Yosef Djakababa (In-Country Representative), Isabella Tirtowalujo (Advisor, AIFIS Fellowships and Strategic Partnerships), Annas Bentari (Program Manager, Jakarta), Yara Zarmansyah (AIFIS Fellowship Program Coordinator, Jakarta), and other AIFIS staff in Jakarta who have worked tirelessly to make this fellowship have a meaningful impact on its recipients. I am truly grateful for the kindness and swift responses from the AIFIS team, who assisted with any inquiries I had during my fellowship term and beyond.

I highly recommend this competitive fellowship to Indonesian scholars who wish to increase their capacity and become impactful scholars in the future. I am pleased to share my wonderful academic journey across continents.
 
 Ratri Istania

AIFIS-Luce Research Fellow 2024

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Memaknai Kebijakan Berorientasi Manusia

Parts of this book can be viewed at Google Book and purchased at Pustaka Obor, Gramedia

Suggested citation: Afrimadona, Dimas R., Rafif P. Imawan, I. Ratri, and D. Shanti. Memaknai Kebijakan Berorientasi Manusia-Sepuluh Pelajaran Berharga Pasca Pandemi COVID-19. Yayasan Pustaka Obor Indonesia, 2022.

This book is firs launched at Populi Center 10th Anniversary Reception

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Territorial Change and Conflict in Indonesia: Confronting the Fear of Secession

This book can be accessed through Routledge, Amazon, Barnes&Noble

Suggested citation: Istania, R. (2022). Territorial Change and Conflict in Indonesia: Confronting the Fear of Secession. Taylor & Francis.

This book focuses on Indonesia and investigates why competition between
various identity-affiliated groups to claim a new province increases conflict
severity. It includes a quantitative study, along with complementary
case studies of provinces in Indonesia, which provide evidence that group
fragmentation plays a role in determining conflict during a new province’s
struggle.


Against the background of the Indonesian government’s territorial
autonomy (TA) strategy, regional proliferation, or pemekaran, the author
examines the long-term decentralization project in Indonesia, which has an
ethnically and religiously divided population. The book provides answers to
the questions of how the new province claim increases conflict in the supporting
districts and how competition among diverse elites in districts pursuing
a new province precipitate conflict within the region. Based on extensive
field research, the four case studies of districts with varying degrees of conflict
reveal that the campaign for a new province proliferation increases the
probability of conflict at the district level and conflict can escalate during
the initiation of a new province stage. The author argues that more provinces
may be necessary to ensure the fair distribution of wealth that would
enable the whole population to enjoy a similar quality of life and that the
Indonesian government needs to wisely and strategically uphold its unity if
a federal arrangement is not an option.


Offering a novel contribution to the study of the relationship between territorial
change and conflict in Indonesia, this book will be of interest to
academics studying Indonesian politics, Southeast Asian politics, as well as
identity and ethnic politics.

Book Excerpts/Testimonies

Territorial Change and Conflict in Indonesia provides a compelling and carefully researched answer to a pressing question in Indonesian politics: how to balance Indonesia’s territorial structure with the interests of its ethnically and religiously diverse population? This book shows how groups press their demands for new provinces, revealing the dynamics of political competition among national, provincial, and local interests over the shape of the local state, and using a comparative approach to explore both successful and unsuccessful cases of territorial change.’

Thomas B. Pepinsky, Cornell University, USA

‘This is a thoughtful and well-researched study for those interested in identity politics and territoriality in Indonesia and more generally.’

Ehito Kimura, University of Hawai’i at Manoa, Hawaii

‘This is an excellent book that studies the relationships between the development of new provinces and conflict in Indonesia. Combining both quantitative research and in-depth case studies, the author elucidates the mechanism by which variables combine to produce various conflicts outcomes. This book is highly recommended for anyone who is interested in territorial integrity and conflicts.’

Eunsook Jung, University of Wisconsin-Madison, USA

Preview of this book is available below.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

At the most challenging G20 in history, can Indonesia run a successful summit?

This article is co-authored with Shanti Darmastuti and already published in The Conversation on November 15, 2022 while Bali Summit was about to end.

Indonesia is holding the G20 Summit in Bali on November 15-16. Heads of states from the world’s largest economies are attending – although Russian President Vladimir Putin has decided not to attend in-person.

However with unstable global political conditions due to the COVID-19 pandemic, the war in Ukraine, energy issues, as well as global economic downturn, this is believed to be the most challenging G20 summit yet.

A number of important G20 working group meetings failed to produce a communiqué (a drafted consensus statement expressing members’ commitments and vision for the future).

As the host country, Indonesia has worked hard to prove that the G20 summit is able to produce some solutions to reduce, if not overcome, the global crisis caused by the COVID-19 pandemic and current political instability.

Read full article at the most challenging G20 in history

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

G20 tersulit dalam sejarah, mampukah Indonesia mengakhiri konferensi internasional ini dengan sukses?

Artikel ini ditulis bersama Shanti Darmastuti dan telah diterbitkan di The Conversation Indonesia pada November 11, 2022

Pada 15-16 November 2022, Konferensi Tingkat Tinggi (KTT) G20 akan berlangsung di Bali.

Sebagai tuan rumah, Indonesia telah bekerja ekstra keras untuk membuktikan bahwa forum internasional yang akan dihadiri para kepala negara dari ekonomi terbesar di dunia ini akan mampu menghasilkan solusi untuk mengatasi krisis global akibat pandemi COVID-19.

Namun, fakta yang terjadi adalah: kondisi politik global semakin tidak stabil akibat perang, sejumlah pertemuan vital Kelompok Kerja (Working Groups) G20 gagal mencapai deklarasi maupun kesepakatan, dan Presiden Rusia Vladimir Putin – yang kini menjadi pusat perhatian – memutuskan untuk tidak datang dan tidak menghadiri langsung KTT G20.

Legitimasi dan akuntabilitas forum G20 sebagai wadah kerja sama multilateral kini tengah dipertanyakan, dan akan menjadi salah satu penentu masa depan kerja sama multilateral informal antara negara-negara besar ke depannya.

Selebihnya: Klik tautan G20 tersulit dalam sejarah

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

The Struggling Aristocrats? Noble Families’ Diminishing Roles after theSplitting of Tana Toraja Region

This article is published in Southeast Asian Studies Journal (Kyoto)

Suggested citation:

Istania, Ratri (2022). The Struggling Aristocrats? Noble Families’ Diminishing Roles after
the Splitting of Tana Toraja Region. Southeast Asian Studies, Vol. 11, No. 2, August
2022, pp. 195-218. DOI: 10.20495/seas.11.2_195.

How did the splitting of the Tana Toraja region in 2008 challenge the local aristocrats’ dual role in adat and politics in the new North Toraja? Why and how did these aristocrats fail to secure their dual role after the 2015 election? After 32 years of the New Order regime, adat rights were finally revived through the Return to Lembang regulation in 2001. The law channelled noble families’ hereditary rights back to local political affairs. However, the splitting of the region, or pemekaran daerah, opened a new venue for power contestation in North Toraja District. Following the second direct local head election in 2015, noble families’ role in politics gradually diminished due to the participation of a growing class of wealthy and politically strong non-traditional elites in democratic elections. Using interviews, triangulated with government archives and media resources, I extend previous studies of North Toraja aristocrats’ advantage to reassert their dual role—in adat and politics—after the region’s split. I argue that decentralization policies initiated through democratic elections came with high risks for aristocrats to again secure their traditional hereditary rights. This study was inspired by Lee Ann Fujii’s (2014) accidental ethnography study based on stories and unplanned encounters in Bosnia, Rwanda, and other places. It aims to contribute to an understanding of decentralization and indigenous minority groups’ survival in Indonesia’s multicultural society.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

How Do Ethnic Groups Compete for a New Province in a Decentralised Indonesia?

This is a pre-proof version of the already published article on Asian Journal of Political Science.

Suggested Citation: Istania, Ratri (2021). How do ethnic groups compete for a new province in a decentralised Indonesia?, Asian Journal of Political Science, 29:3, 316-337, DOI: 10.1080/02185377.2021.1993944

ABSTRACT

How do ethnic groups compete in a decentralized Indonesia? How do their political competitions to claim a new province lead to open conflict? The Indonesian government devised its massive territorial autonomy (TA) strategy—regional proliferation or pemekaran—as part of expansive decentralization reform in 1999. While scholarship is generally ambiguous regarding the relationship between regional proliferation and conflict, many districts still experience small-scale episodic conflict some of which may be fuelled by ethnic-group competition after pemekaran. This study aims to investigate ethnic groups’ political competition during the initiation stage of non-successful new province campaigns. Using four cases—two new province aspirations, one no-province claim and a null case—I argue that ethnic groups’ political competition can develop to the level of a localized small-scale episodic conflict. The evidence suggests that political competition among ethnic groups may temporarily escalate due issues of the location of the new province’s capital location and the future bid for a new gubernatorial position. This study fills a scholarly gap in the discussion of ethnic groups’ politics and conflict (e.g. Cederman et al. 2015; Cunningham 2014). Furthermore, this study finds support for the effectiveness of a moratorium policy, such as buying-time tactics to reduce the conflict.

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Apa kata peneliti soal perombakan kabinet Jokowi di penghujung 2020?

December 22, 2020 9.41am EST

Presiden Joko “Jokowi” Widodo menuju penghujung 2020, tahun bersejarah yang ditandai pandemi global, protes masyarakat terhadap Omnibus Law, resesi ekonomi, skandal korupsi di pemerintahan, merombak susunan kabinetnya.

Jokowi pada akhirnya mencopot Terawan Putranto dari posisi Menteri Kesehatan yang telah gagal mengantisipasi keparahan pandemi COVID-19. Ia menunjuk bankir Budi Gunadi Sadikin sebagai Menteri Kesehatan yang baru.

Posisi Menteri Kelautan dan Perikanan yang kosong akibat skandal korupsi yang menimpa Eddhy Prabowo kini diisi mantan Wakil Menteri Pertahanan dan pengusaha Sakti Wahyu Trenggono.

Jokowi menunjuk Tri Rismaharini, Wali Kota Surabaya, sebagai Menteri Sosial menggantikan Juliari Batubara yang ditangkap karena dugaan korupsi bantuan sosial COVID-19. Sebagai Menteri Perdagangan yang baru, Jokowi menunjuk M. Luthfi, Duta Besar Indonesia di Amerika Serikat, yang pernah menjabat posisi Menteri Perdagangan pada pemerintahan Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono.

Jokowi juga mengganti Menteri Agama dengan menunjuk Yaqut Cholil Qoumas, Ketua Umum Gerakan Pemuda (GP) Ansor – sebuah organisasi kemasyarakatan pemuda yang berafiliasi dengan Nahdlatul Ulama. Yaqut juga anggota DPR dari Partai Kebangkitan Bangsa (PKB).

Dengan mengangkat Sandiaga Uno sebagai Menteri Pariwisata dan Ekonomi Kreatif, Jokowi melengkapi kabinetnya dengan pasangan oposisinya dalam pemilihan presiden (pilpres) tahun lalu. Sandiaga berlaga melawan Jokowi dalam pilpres tahun lalu sebagai calon wakil presiden Prabowo Subianto, yang kini menjabat Menteri Pertahanan.

Kami bertanya pada para akademisi dan peneliti terkait enam menteri baru Jokowi dan apa yang bisa kita harapkan dari perombakan kabinet ini.

Indonesia butuh Menteri Kesehatan yang mampu memimpin

Irwandy, Peneliti Kesehatan Masyarakat Universitas Hasanuddin Makassar

Di tengah kinerja Kementerian Kesehatan yang dianggap lemah dan tak kunjung menunjukkan perbaikan dalam menghadapi pandemi COVID-19, Jokowi mengambil kebijakan besar: menunjuk Budi Gunadi Sadikin, bankir yang sebelumnya menjabat Wakil Menteri Badan Usaha Milik Negara (BUMN), sebagai Menteri Kesehatan yang baru.

Langkah ini menimbulkan pro dan kontra dengan satu pertanyaan mendasar: apakah di tengah pandemi COVID-19 langkah ini tepat? Budi Sadikin bukan seorang dokter, bahkan sama sekali tidak memiliki latar belakang di bidang kesehatan.

Sebenarnya Kementerian Kesehatan punya dua peran utama yakni peran teknis kesehatan dan peran pemimpin yang mampu mengkoordinasi dan membangun kepercayaan di antara para stakeholder kesehatan.

Di banyak negara-negara maju seperti Belanda, Amerika Serikat, Singapura, Thailand, Kanada, Jerman hingga Selandia Baru Kementerian Kesehatannya tidak dipimpin oleh seorang berlatar belakang kesehatan.

Selandia Baru dan Singapura yang sukses mengendalikan pandemi COVID-19 saat ini memiliki Menteri Kesehatan yang bukan seorang dokter, bahkan tidak memiliki latar belakang pendidikan bidang kesehatan.

Namun perlu diingat bahwa sistem birokrasi, tugas pokok dan fungsi kementerian kesehatan di negara-negara tersebut sangat jauh berbeda dengan Indonesia. Di sana, Kementerian Kesehatan benar-benar diposisikan sebagai lembaga yang mengatur kebijakan dan manajerial kesehatan secara umum. Sementara fungsi-fungsi pelaksanaan kegiatan teknis dijalankan oleh beberapa institusi yang bersifat otonom.

Dalam penanganan pandemi COVID-19, di negara-negara tersebut kita sangat jarang mendengar peran kementerian kesehatan. Namun yang menonjol adalah peran dari lembaga independen seperti Center of Communicable Diseases (CDC) di Amerika Serikat dan untuk persoalan vaksin yang hangat sekarang ini peran itu menjadi tanggung jawab Food and Drug Administration (FDA).

Di Indonesia lembaga-lembaga teknis otonom ini baru Badan Pengawas Obat dan Makanan (BPOM). Selebihnya, masih sangat birokratis melekat di Kementerian Kesehatan.

Oleh karena itu, langkah yang diambil presiden saat ini sebenarnya bukan tidak tepat, bahkan cenderung baik di tengah pekerjaan rumah besar kementerian untuk mengendalikan penularan COVID-19 dan distribusi vaksin COVID. Presiden membutuhkan kemampuan manajerial dan pengalaman panjang yang dimiliki Budi Gunadi Sadikin.

Namun catatan pentingnya adalah fungsi-fungsi Kementerian Kesehatan di Indonesia terlalu banyak yang bersifat teknis. Sementara pada era pandemi seperti saat ini salah satu fungsi kepemimpinan yang dibutuhkan di bidang kesehatan adalah pemimpin yang dapat membangun kepercayaan seluruh stakeholder kesehatan termasuk masyarakat.

Oleh karena itu agar langkah ini dapat berhasil, sudah saatnya Kementerian Kesehatan dikembangkan. Kita perlu sebuah institusi yang disebut Indonesia Center of Communicable Diseases yang harus dipimpin oleh orang-orang yang benar-benar memiliki kompetensi di bidang kesehatan masyarakat untuk menjadi pemimpin dan membangun trust agar “perang melawan COVID” ini dapat segera kita menangkan.

Selanjutnya Kementerian Kesehatan seharusnya fokus pada fungsi regulator dan manajerial umum, yang fungsi ini tidak lagi perlu dijalankan oleh seorang dokter atau ahli kesehatan kesehatan.

Potensi ekonomi lebih dipentingkan dibandingkan kesehatan

Bhima Yudhistira Adhinegara, Peneliti Institute for Development of Economics and Finance (INDEF)

Susunan kabinet dan reshuffle atau pergantian menteri kali ini cukup unik, karena orang bidang ekonomi justru ditempatkan di bidang kesehatan.

Dengan pergantian ini ada kemungkinan Jokowi ingin menjadikan kesehatan nomor dua dan persoalan pandemi diselesaikan dengan ekonomi. Kemungkinan lain, ada ketidakpercayaan pada pada jajaran kementerian kesehatan sehingga Jokowi merasa perlu menunjuk eksekutor yang memahami bisnis.

Orang yang menggantikan Terawan Agus Putranto sebagai Menteri kesehatan adalah Budi Gunadi Sadikin, yang sebelumnya adalah Ketua Satuan Tugas Pemulihan Ekonomi Nasional (Satgas PEN) dan wakil Menteri Badan Usaha Milik Negara (BUMN).

Budi tidak memiliki latar belakang di bidang kesehatan, ia paling dikenal sebagai seorang bankir dan puncaknya adalah menjadi Direktur Utama Bank Mandiri periode 2013-2016. Setelah itu ia menjadi Direktur Utama PT Indonesia Asahan Alumunium ( Inalum) pada 2017-2019. Di masa kepemimpinannya, Inalum berhasil memiliki 51% saham PT Freeport Indonesia.

Jika posisi Menteri Kesehatan diberikan ke pebisnis maka kebijakannya bisa tidak selaras dengan penanganan COVID-19 yang lebih saintifik dan berbasiskan data, melainkan berdasarkan untung rugi bisnis.

Seharusnya ada orang yang lebih kompeten dan menguasai bidang kesehatan masyarakat, dari jajaran birokrat karier, ataupun akademisi sehingga kebijakannya bisa lebih terukur dan berbasiskan data.

Pergantian yang tepat hanya ada di sosok Muhammad Lutfi yang menggantikan Agus Suparmanto sebagai Menteri Perdagangan.

Muhammad Lutfi memiliki latar belakang di dunia usaha, ia dikenal sebagai salah satu pendiri Mahaka Group yang banyak bergerak di bidang media bersama dengan Erick Thohir, Wishnu Wardhana, dan Harry Zulnardy.

Sebelumnya ia adalah duta besar Indonesia untuk Amerika Serikat, dan dalam hal ekonomi ia pernah menjabat sebagai kepala Badan Koordinasi Penanaman Modal ( BKPM ) dan Menteri Perdagangan pada masa pemerintahan Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono.

Terkait perdagangan, Muhammad Lutfi adalah sosok yang tepat karena memiliki kompetensi, jaringan bisnis cukup luas, dan sebelumnya juga pernah menjadi Mendag sehingga bisa langsung bekerja di Menteri Perdagangan.

Sementara posisi menteri yang lain seperti Menteri Sosial yang diisi oleh Tri Rismaharini dan Sandiaga Uno yang menjadi Menteri Pariwisata dan Ekonomi Kreatif (Menparekraf) merupakan penunjukan yang bernuansa politis.

Ada beberapa pos yang langsung bisa bekerja, dan ada pos yang perlu mempelajari proses birokrasi karena sebelumnya belum pernah menjadi menteri, ini yang jadi tantangan, bagaimana kolaborasi antar menteri yang baru ini bisa lebih cepat menangani pandemi dan stimulus ekonomi tahun depan.

Membangun kembali kepercayaan publik dalam sektor kelautan dan perikanan

Zainal Arifin, Peneliti Senior, Pusat Penelitian Oseanografi, Lembaga Ilmu Pengetahuan Indonesia (LIPI)

Kementerian Kelautan dan Perikanan (KKP) di bawah Sakti Wahyu Trenggono perlu membangun kepercayaan publik terhadap kinerja KKP. Selama ini, perubahan kebijakan dalam KKP antara periode pertama pemerintahan Jokowi, ketika posisi Menteri KKP di bawah Susi Pujiastuti, dan periode kedua di bawah Edhy Prabowo – yang baru-baru ini terjerat kasus korupsi – sangat ekstrem.

Pada masa Susi Pujiastuti, semuanya sangat ketat: cantrang dilarang, kapal nelayan asing ditenggelamkan, sumber daya perikanan diperoteksi. Kemudian pada masa Edhy Prabowo, hampir semua yang dicanangkan Susi diubah: cantrang diperbolehkan, benih lobster boleh diekspor.

Perubahan ini seperti pendulum yang berayun sangat lebar.

Sakti perlu memberikan kepastian berusaha dan kepastian hukum bagi para nelayan, baik nelayan tradisional maupun nelayan industri. Terlebih karena situasi pandemi masih akan panjang – trennya 2021 kita belum lepas dari pandemi COVID-19. Jika sumber daya perikanan dikelola dengan bijak dan konsisten, maka sektor perikanan kita bisa mendorong pertumbuhan ekonomi dan kesejahteraan masyarakat dalam jangka panjang.

Persyaratan mendasar yang perlu ada pada Menteri KKP adalah integritas dan komitmen untuk membangun kelautan perikanan yang mensejahterakan tidak saja sebagian masyarakat, tapi juga semua stakeholder yang terlibat dalam industri perikanan dan kelautan. Dengan kedua hal tersebut, latar belakang keahlian di bidang perikanan dan kelautan bukan suatu keharusan, karena menteri dapat mengangkat staf ahli yang memberi masukan. Selain itu ada juga dukungan para direktur jenderal berpengalaman dan punya pengetahuan mendalam mengenai isu kelautan dan perikanan.

Saya kira dengan pengalaman sebagai pengusaha, menteri baru akan sangat mampu memimpin KKP untuk meningkatkan produksi perikanan. Hanya satu hal yang perlu kita cermati dan terus awasi, yaitu kebijakan pemanfaatan sumberdaya perikanan keberlanjutan dan upaya konservasi harus seiring.

KKP selain mendorong produksi perikanan, baik untuk ekspor maupun kebutuhan dalam negeri, perlu juga memastikan bahwa ada keseimbangan antara produksi dan upaya pemanfaatan sumber daya perikanan yang berkelanjutan. Semangatnya perlu sesuai dengan Sustainable Development Goals (SDGs), terutama SDG 14 “life below water”, untuk tidak hanya memanfaatkan sumber daya yang ada tapi juga upaya konsevasi.

Mengembalikan Kementerian Agama ke alur konvensional

Achmad Munjid, Pengajar bidang ilmu budaya dan Peneliti Senior di Universitas Gadjah Mada (UGM)

Pengangkatan Yaqut Cholil Qoumas, seorang tokoh muda NU, sebagai Menteri Agama menggantikan Fachrul Razi menunjukkan upaya pemulihan pengelolaan kementerian itu ke alur konvensional.

Bukan cuma tak berprestasi, sejak bulan pertama menjabat, Fahrul Razi kerap membuat pernyataan blunder, dari mulai rencana pelarangan cadar dan celana cingkrang hingga sertifikasi dai.

Pendekatannya yang terlalu militeristik membuat komunikasinya dengan publik maupun komunitas agama tidak efektif.

Fachrul adalah seorang pensiunan jenderal TNI; ia lulus Akademi Angkatan Bersenjata Republik Indonesia (Akabri) pada tahun 1970.

Dengan obsesi Fachrul yang berlebihan terhadap ancaman radikalisme, fungsi pelayanan Kementerian Agama yang mestinya lebih utama justru jadi tertutup oleh kehendak kontrol terpusat pemerintah.

Di tengah naiknya isu radikalisme dan kontroversi Front Pembela Islam (FPI), pemilihan Yaqut mengindikasikan prioritas Jokowi dalam pengelolaan kehidupan beragama belum jauh bergeser.

Yaqut harus melangkah hati-hati supaya tidak mengulang kontroversi dan polarisasi yang tak perlu seperti pendahulunya.

Jangan sampai NU hanya jadi tameng di tengah problem politik identitas yang memburuk terutama sejak sekitar pemilihan presiden 2014.

Yaqut perlu menawarkan langkah-langkah strategis yang bisa meredam persoalan tanpa memancing kekisruhan baru.

Lebih dari soal radikalisme, yang meskipun krusial tapi tak boleh terlalu menyita energi, ia perlu menentukan target-target jangka pendek maupun panjang.

Transparansi dan efisiensi manajemen haji/umroh dan pengelolaan lembaga pendidikan agama perlu menjadi prioritas.

Tri Rismaharini, pilihan strategis Jokowi untuk 2024

Ratri Istania, Postgraduate Research Fellow Political Science Loyola University Chicago, Asisten Dosen Poltek STIA LAN Jakarta

Penunjukan Tri Rismaharini, Wali Kota Surabaya dua periode 2010-2015 dan 2015-2020, merupakan pilihan strategis Jokowi untuk turut mengamankan roda pemerintahan 2024. Belakangan ini, Kabinet Indonesia maju limbung diterpa badai korupsi. Dua Menteri tertangkap tangan Komisi Pemberantasan Korupsi (KPK) dalam waktu berdekatan di pengujung 2020. Salah satunya adalah Menteri Sosial Julian P. Batubara, kader dari PDI Perjuangan (PDI-P).

Tri Rismaharini bukan pemain baru dalam peta percaturan politik lokal. Nama dia sudah sering kali masuk dalam sirkulasi elit politik nasional. Sebagai tokoh politik lokal dengan segudang pengalaman memimpin, Risma sempat digadang-gadang menjadi kandidat Gubernur DKI Jakarta sampai calon presiden RI. Namun Risma tetap amanah, menuntaskan periode kepemimpinan sebagai Wali Kota Surabaya sampai selesai.

Keberadaan Risma sebagai pemimpin perempuan tidak perlu diragukan lagi.

Oleh karena itu, tidak mengherankan, jika PDI-P sebagai partai pemenang di wilayah Jawa Timur, meminang Risma untuk mendampingi Bambang D.H., pejabat Wali Kota Surabaya alias atasan langsung Risma menjelang pemilihan wali kota pada 2010. Dorongan atasan sebagai mentor politik sekaligus restu petinggi partai, Ketua Umum PDIP Megawati Soekarnoputri, melancarkan jalan Risma menjadi Wali Kota dua periode.

Kelancaran jalan Risma sebagai Menteri Sosial sekarang inipun tidak terlepas dari faktor-faktor pendukung tersebut.

Studi tentang perempuan dan politik di negara-negara demokrasi non-Barat mengidentifikasi tantangan berat pemimpin perempuan berhadapan dengan masalah kultural dan nilai konservatif agama. Ditambah, sering kali media masa mempertanyakan kemampuan perempuan dalam memimpin terutama dalam lingkungan dominasi laki-laki.

Namun demikian, hasil peneliti saya dan tim di Penelitian Pusat Studi Gender dan Birokrasi Politeknik STIA LAN Jakarta, yang akan terbit, menunjukkan kesuksesan Risma sebagai pemimpin tidak terlepas dari peran media masa, baik lokal, seperti Jawa Pos, maupun nasional membesarkan namanya.

Terlepas dari sosoknya yang cenderung emosional, Risma berani tampil sebagai dirinya sendiri. Dia terkenal sebagai sosok yang relatif imun dari korupsi.

Kombinasi kepemimpinan unik Risma, ditambah dengan komitmennya pada rakyat jelata tentu menjadikannya sosok strategis di mata Jokowi dan terlebih Megawati sebagai tokoh besar partai pendukung.

Singkat kata, Risma berhasil breaking the glass ceiling karena dia bukan pemimpin perempuan biasa. Risma merupakan inspirasi bagi perempuan-perempuan Indonesia.

Artikel selengkapnya dapat disimak di The Conversation Indonesia Apa Kata Peneliti Perombakan Kabinet

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized

Pilihan Calon Anggota Kabinet Biden Dipuji

25/11/2020

By Eva Mazrieva

Pilihan calon anggota kabinet Biden yang berwarna dan berisi pejabat karier dengan portofolio kuat dipuji banyak kalangan dan dinilai akan memuluskan kinerja pemerintahannya.

Presiden terpilih Joe Biden, Senin (23/11) mengisyaratkan niatnya menominasikan beberapa tokoh untuk posisi strategis dalam pemerintahannya.

Isyarat ini disampaikannya seusai pertemuan virtualnya bersama pendampingnya Kamala Harris dengan US Conference of Mayors, sebuah lembaga swadaya masyarakat (LSM) non partisan yang anggotanya mencakup wali kota dari lebih 1.400 kota, yang masing-masing berpenduduk 300 ribu atau lebih, di kediamannya di Wilmington, Delaware.

Biden mengisyaratkan memilih Anthony Blinken, veteran pengambilan keputusan untuk berbagai urusan luar negeri Amerika yang telah berdinas selama lebih dari dua puluh tahun, sejak di era pemerintahan Bill Clinton, George Walker Bush hingga Barack Obama. Blinken, yang berusia 58 tahun, selama ini juga dikenal sebagai penasehat dekat Biden dalam bidang luar negeri.

Biden juga mengambil pilihan yang tidak biasa, dengan memilih pengacara Amerika keturunan Kuba, Alejandro Mayorkas, untuk memimpin Departemen Keamanan Dalam Negeri. Jika dikonfirmasi Senat, Mayorkas akan menjadi orang Amerika Latin dan imigran pertama yang menduduki posisi itu.

Beberapa Tokoh Perempuan Ikut Dipilih

Tanpa ragu Biden memilih beberapa perempuan untuk posisi penting lainnya. Linda Thomas-Greenfield, warga Amerika keturunan Afrika yang sudah berdinas selama 35 tahun di empat benua, di bawah payung US Foreign Service, dipilihnya sebagai Duta Besar Amerika untuk PBB.

Sementara mantan wakil direktur Badan Intelijen Pusat (Central Intelligence Agency/CIA), Avril Haines, dipilihnya menjadi Direktur Badan Intelijen Nasional. Ia akan menjadi perempuan pertama yang memimpin komunitas intelijen Amerika.

Biden juga diperkirakan akan memilih mantan Direktur Bank Sentral Amerika Janet Yellen untuk menjadi menteri keuangannya.

Diwawancarai VOA melalui telpon, Dr. Ratri Istania di Loyola University, Chicago, mengatakan pilihan Biden ini mewujudkan janjinya untuk menghadirkan kabinet yang mencerminkan Amerika.

“Ini kabinet yang akan sangat colorful, berwarna. Ada Alejandro Mayorkas, Anthony Blinken, Linda Thomas-Greenfield, Avril Haines, dan lain-lain. Ini hawa baik buat Amerika karena Biden sesuai janji kampanye dan pidato kemenangannya ingin sekali menghadirkan kepemimpinan dan pemerintahan yang merepresentasikan Amerika, dari segi etnis, ras hingga jenis kelamin. Ia juga ingin menunjukkan target utamanya setelah pelantikan nanti yaitu melawan Covid-19 dan memulihkan perekonomian.”

Hal senada disampaikan Dr. Abdul Malik Gismar di Paramadina Public Policy Institute, yang menilai pilihan Biden ini merupakan sosok yang “aman,” tidak saja supaya dapat lolos dalam sidang konfirmasi Senat nanti, tetapi juga sebagai orang-orang yang dikenal setia pada Biden.

“Selain supaya bisa lolos di Senat, karena ia masih harus dikonfirmasi dulu nantinya, mereka-mereka ini sudah puluhan tahun bekerjasama dengan Biden dan berdinas di bawah pemerintahan Obama. Jadi jelas loyalitasnya, integritasnya dan merit pengalamannya. Saya melihat ini komposisi yang menarik, yang ingin menunjukkan kembalinya Amerika pada peran sentral di dunia. Menunjukkan postur politik Amerika yang jelas, tidak seperti sebelumnya. Jelas, dalam arti dunia tahu bagaimana harus bersikap, bukan berarti serta merta setuju dengan kebijakan Biden kelak.”

Mantan Pejabat Pemerintahan Trump Ikut Dorong Kebijakan Multilateralisme

Lebih jauh Dr. Ratri Istania mengutip pernyataan Jim Mattis di “Foreign Affairs” edisi Senin (23/11) yang meminta agar pemerintahan mendatang “meninggalkan” semua agenda “Amerika First” yang digaungkan Presiden Donald Trump.

“Ketika Presiden Joe Biden dan tim keamanan nasionalnya mulai mengevaluasi kembali kebijakan luar negeri Amerika Januari nanti, kami berharap mereka dapat dengan cepat merevisi strategi keamanan nasional untuk meninggalkan ‘Amerika First’ dari isinya, memulihkan komitmen untuk kerjasama keamanan yang telah dijalankan dengan sangat baik oleh Amerika selama puluhan tahun.”

“Ini mantan menteri pertahanan Trump lho yang bicara. Ia mengakui bahwa retorika ‘Amerika First’ justru mengisolasi Amerika ketimbang menikmati leverage dari multilateralisme atau kerjasama dengan berbagai kepentingan di luar Amerika. Sudah bukan waktunya membuat Amerika semakin terpinggirkan dan terpuruk, dan membuat kekosongan kepemimpinan di dunia diisi oleh Rusia atau China,” kata Dr.Ratri.

195 Perintah Eksekutif Trump

Selain mengambil kebijakan yang berbeda dengan Trump, Biden diperkirakan juga akan mengakhiri dan mengubah 195 perintah eksekutif yang dikeluarkan Trump selama menjabat. Antara lain kebijakan pembatasan imigrasi bagi warga dari tujuh negara mayoritas Muslim, Deferred Action for Childhood Arrivals (DACA) atau program perlindungan bagi ratusan ribu anak imigran yang dibawa orang tua mereka sewaktu masih kanak-kanak agar tidak dideportasi, kebijakan meninggalkan Perjanjian Iklim Paris atau keluar dari keanggotaan Badan Kesehatan Dunia (WHO), hingga pembangunan tembok di perbatasan selatan Amerika.

Kedua pengamat yang diwawancarai VOA mengatakan hal-hal ini penting dilakukan segera jika Amerika ingin kembali menata ulang postur politiknya dan meraih kembali kepercayaan publik dunia. [em/ab]

Artikel selengkapnya dapat disimak di VoA Indonesia Pilihan Anggota Kabinet Biden

Leave a comment

Filed under Uncategorized